Youth Opportunity Is No Less Than Public Service Reform 

 

By Chloe Piggott, Amy Long, Blair Parkinson, Yusuf Ur-Rehman, and Nina Newhouse

The Milburn review gives places a significant opportunity, not simply to tackle youth unemployment, but to rethink how public services, employers, communities and the economy work together to enable young people to participate and prosper.  

Its diagnosis is fundamentally one of fragmentation. Young people experience education, health, housing, skills, transport, employment and family circumstances together; the state too often responds through separate programmes, institutions and funding streams. The answer cannot be another service or another hub.  

The bigger opportunity is to build participation into the way a place works: shifting towards prevention, connecting public service reform to economic growth and giving young people greater agency in shaping and sharing in their place’s prosperity.  

So what might that look like in practice? 

Start with the person, not the programme 

Young people don't disengage from education or employment in isolation. Disengagement can reflect compounding factors such as poverty, mental ill health and SEND, which no single institution can address alone. Risks can often be identified early, but responsibility to intervene remains fragmented across institutions, programmes and tiers of government.  

A participation system should start by asking: who is at risk of being unable to participate, why, and what needs to change around them?  

That means shifting from asking how young people change to fit the system to working with them to shape their future. Trusted relationships matter: people who can help young people navigate towards employment with their own ambitions, not those of the state, at the heart of the conversation.  

But it also means connecting rather than duplicating what already exists: schools identifying participation risk earlier; EHCPs focusing more explicitly on continued participation in education or employment; and employment opportunities being considered within growth, social care transformation and transport planning. Prevention, in other words, becomes everybody’s business.  

In Fife, our No Wrong Door work has gone beyond exploring what a more integrated response might look like. We have helped the council and its partners design the model and put in place the operational arrangements needed to make it work, organising support around people rather than service silos. It reflects a simple reality: employment outcomes are often inseparable from the wider circumstances shaping people's lives, and reform must translate from policy into delivery. 

Strategic authorities can change the equation 

Strategic authorities bring different levers: transport, skills, investment, planning and relationships with major employers. Used together, they can help shape regional economies that young people contribute to and share in. The Milburn review proposes giving them responsibility for the 16-to-24 participation system, alongside greater powers, funding and commissioning freedoms.  

But simply moving commissioning up a tier risks recreating two-tier government at a larger scale.  

Instead, strategic authorities can give member councils a regional lens and a platform to be more ambitious together. Young people don't live their lives within local authority boundaries; neither do transport networks, labour markets or opportunities. The opportunity is for local and regional government to work to shared principles, combining their different strengths rather than imposing a fixed divide between “strategic” and “operational”.  

Our work with Mayoral Strategic Authorities is showing what this can look like. Through public service reform, we are working with partners to connect growth, prevention, health and wider social outcomes and tackle barriers that existing structures struggle to resolve. An authority’s role in shaping its regional economy can itself be preventative.  

Connect prevention to prosperity 

Participation cannot only be about fixing problems in public services. There must be something meaningful to participate in.  

The Milburn review proposes a different bargain with employers, including more first jobs, apprenticeships and meaningful work experience, alongside using public procurement to create youth opportunity. 

That starts to connect public service reform directly to local growth and raises different questions for a place: 

What does prosperity mean to young people and communities here? Where is value created, who can contribute to it, and who is excluded? What needs to change so young people can help shape that economy and share in the value it creates?  

For us, this points towards a broader idea of participation, starting with young people's agency. Young people shouldn’t simply be future workers prepared for an existing economy. They should have the opportunity to shape, contribute to and share in the prosperity of their place, through work and learning but also through the assets, relationships and opportunities that give them agency within their communities. 

Public service reform has a role on both sides of that equation: helping people overcome the conditions that prevent them participating, while shaping places and economies in which they have something meaningful to participate in. 

The prize is therefore much greater than a better employment service. It is a place where young people can build secure and meaningful lives, contribute to the economy and community around them, and have a stake in how their place develops. That requires public services, employers, communities and strategic authorities to work together: spotting risk earlier and helping young people stay engaged, while shaping an economy in which participation can lead to prosperity. That is the opportunity the Milburn review creates: not another programme or hub, but a chance to rethink how places enable young people to participate and prosper. 

If you’re interested in joining us for a conversation around this topic, feel free to message our Managing Directors Evie John ([email protected]) and Chris Naylor ([email protected]).

Next
Next

Growth in every postcode is the wrong ambition, sort of